Perfect For Every Occasion
-
Valentine's Day - order ahead, our most popular day for heart-shaped pizza
-
Anniversaries - a fun, memorable twist on date night
-
Birthdays & Galentine's parties - great as a shareable centerpiece
-
"Just because" - available year-round, not just February
Choose any topping combination — Margherita, pepperoni, or build your own. Available in our standard size, ready in about 20-25 minutes.
What Makes Our Heart Shaped Pizza Special
Some things are better when they're made from scratch, by hand, the way pizza was always meant to be made. Our heart shaped pizza is the same hand-tossed dough, the same fresh tomato sauce, and the same melted mozzarella we've been making in the East Village since 1997 — just shaped with a little more love.
Whether you're celebrating Valentine's Day, an anniversary, a birthday, or just a Tuesday that deserves something special, our heart pizza makes any moment memorable. Customize it with your favorite toppings, and we'll have it ready for pickup or delivery anywhere in Manhattan.
Fresh, Classic NYC Pizza Made Daily
From classic cheese slices, heart shaped pizza to specialty pizzas, every pie is made fresh with quality ingredients and baked to perfection.
How to Order a Heart Shaped Pizza in NYC
Call or order online
Call us at (212) 529-4545 or order through our website. Let us know you want the heart shaped pizza and your preferred toppings.
Pick your toppings
Classic cheese, pepperoni, fresh basil, mushrooms, sausage — any of our regular toppings work. We recommend keeping it to 2–3 for the best results.
Pickup or delivery
Ready for pickup at 145 1st Ave, East Village, Manhattan. Delivery available throughout the East Village and surrounding neighborhoods.
Heart Shaped Pizza NYC — Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I get a heart-shaped pizza in NYC?
East Village Pizza, located at 145 1st Ave in the East Village, makes fresh heart-shaped pizzas to order year-round — not just for Valentine's Day. Order online for pickup or delivery to the East Village, Union Square, and Lower East Side.
Is heart-shaped pizza available near me in the East Village?
Yes — East Village Pizza delivers heart-shaped pizza throughout the East Village and nearby neighborhoods including Alphabet City, Union Square, and Lower East Side. Order ahead for same-day pickup or delivery.
Do I need to order heart-shaped pizza in advance?
For Valentine's Day and weekends we recommend ordering a few hours ahead, but heart-shaped pizza is available daily with no advance notice required — just call (212) 529-4545 or order online.
Can I customize my heart-shaped pizza toppings?
Yes — our heart-shaped pizza can be made with any topping combination available on our regular menu, from classic Margherita and pepperoni to our specialty pies.
Do you offer heart shaped pizza delivery in NYC?
Yes — we deliver heart shaped pizzas throughout the East Village, Alphabet City, Gramercy, Stuyvesant Town, and surrounding Manhattan neighborhoods. Order by phone or online.
Is heart shaped pizza available year-round?
Absolutely. While it's most popular around Valentine's Day, we make heart shaped pizzas any time of year. It's a great surprise for anniversaries, birthdays, or any special occasion.
How big is the heart shaped pizza?
Our heart shaped pizza is the same size as our standard large.
How far in advance do I need to order?
Same-day orders are usually fine — call us to check availability. For Valentine's Day and holiday weekends, we recommend ordering at least 1–2 days ahead.
Can I customize my heart shaped pizza?
Yes — any of our regular toppings work on the heart pizza. We recommend keeping it to 2–3 toppings for the cleanest shape.
Made in the East Village Since 1997
East Village Pizza has been a Manhattan neighborhood institution for over 25 years. We're not a chain, not a franchise — just a family-run pizzeria that's been slinging some of NYC's best pizza at 145 1st Ave since before Yelp existed.
When you order a heart shaped pizza from us, it's made fresh by hand the same way every other pizza we make is. No shortcuts. Just real New York pizza, shaped with a little more intention.
Order the Best Heart Shaped NYC Pizza
Stop by our East Village location or order online for fast pickup and delivery. Whether you’re a local or visiting NYC, East Village Pizza is your destination for authentic Manhattan pizza.