Pizza prices in NYC
How Much Is a Slice of Pizza in NYC? Here's What We Charge
A cheese slice at East Village Pizza is $4.99 and a whole 18-inch cheese pie is $27.99. Every price on this page comes from our current menu at 145 1st Avenue, where we've made New York-style pizza since 1997.
Slice Prices
- Cheese slice: $4.99
- Sicilian square slice: $5.50
- Extra cheese slice: $6.25
- White slice (mozzarella, ricotta and pecorino, no sauce): $6.50
- Pepperoni, Margherita, Buffalo chicken, BBQ chicken, mushroom, vegetable, baked ziti, pepperoni jalapeño and Sicilian pepperoni slices: $6.89 each
Two cheese slices and a can of soda come to $12.23 before tax.
Whole 18-Inch Pie Prices
Every 18-inch pie is cut into 8 slices. A cheese pie at $27.99 works out to about $3.50 a slice.
- Cheese, or create your own: $27.99
- Mushroom: $28.99
- White: $29.99
- Pepperoni or extra cheese: $30.99
- Margherita, or pepperoni and mushroom: $32.99
- Buffalo chicken, BBQ chicken, pepperoni jalapeño, pepperoni sausage or baked ziti: $33.99
- Meat lover or the combo (everything): $36.11
- Vegetable: $36.99
Specialty Pies, Gluten-Free and Bundles
- Double-stacked pizza, two full 18-inch pies baked as one: $47
- Heart-shaped pizza: $27.99 to $32.99
- Sicilian 16-inch square pies: $26.99 to $31.99
- 12-inch gluten-free pizzas: $17.99 to $27.99 (the crust is gluten-free, but our kitchen isn't, so we don't recommend them for anyone with celiac disease)
- Calzones: $15 to $18. See every calzone.
- Pizza Party Bundle, three 18-inch pies (cheese, pepperoni and Margherita): $80, which is $11.97 less than ordering them separately
What You Get for $4.99
Each slice is one-eighth of an 18-inch pie: thin in the middle, crisp at the edge and wide enough to fold the New York way.
The dough cold-ferments for 72 hours before it's stretched by hand and baked on the stone of a Baker's Pride gas deck oven, the same oven we've used since 2003. The sauce is simple and the mozzarella is fresh. Nothing comes from a bag or a freezer.
That's the same pizza at every hour we're open, from 11am until 4am, or 5am Thursday through Saturday.
What a Meal Costs: Four Examples
- Quick lunch for one: a cheese slice and a can of soda, $7.24
- Two people: a pepperoni slice and a Margherita slice ($6.89 each) plus six garlic knots ($4.75), $18.53
- Four people: an 18-inch cheese pie and four cans of soda, $36.99
- Eight people: the Pizza Party Bundle, three 18-inch pies and 24 slices, for $80, about $3.33 a slice
All totals are before New York City sales tax.
Sides, Desserts and Drinks
- Garlic knots, six with marinara: $4.75
- Meatballs, six: $8.99
- Cheesy garlic knots: $15. Cheesy meatball parm: $18
- Mozzarella rolls: $15 to $16.99
- Cheesecake: $6. Tiramisu: $8
- Canned soda: $2.25. Poland Spring water: $1.99. Snapple: $3.25. Gatorade: $3.55. Red Bull: $3.65. Boylan soda: $3.75
- Extra blue cheese, ranch or marinara (2 oz.): $1.50
How to Order
- Walk in at 145 1st Avenue, on the corner of East 9th Street. Slices are ready to go all day.
- Call (212) 529-4545 to order ahead for pickup.
- Order online on Grubhub, Seamless, Uber Eats or DoorDash for pickup or delivery. Each app sets its own delivery area, fees and times, so check your address in the app before you order.
The prices on this page are our current menu prices, checked against the full menu in October 2026.
Pizza Prices — Frequently Asked Questions
How much is a slice of pizza at East Village Pizza?+
A cheese slice is $4.99. A Sicilian square is $5.50, and specialty slices like pepperoni, Margherita and Buffalo chicken are $6.89.
How much is a pizza in NYC?+
At East Village Pizza, slices start at $4.99 and whole 18" pies start at $27.99. Specialty pies like our double-stacked or heart-shaped pizza range from $30-$47.
What's the cheapest thing on the menu?+
A cheese slice is $4.99, and six garlic knots with marinara are $4.75. A whole 18-inch cheese pie is $27.99, which works out to about $3.50 a slice.
Can I customize my pizza?+
Yes — the Create Your Own 18" pizza starts at $27.99, and you can add toppings to the whole pie or just half. A 12" gluten-free create-your-own is also available for $17.99.
Do you have gluten-free pizza?+
Yes, a full 12" gluten-free menu is available: Cheese, White, Margherita, Vegetable, Mushroom, Olives, or build your own. The crust is gluten-free, but our kitchen is not a gluten-free facility, so we don't recommend it for anyone with celiac disease.
Is there a deal for groups?+
Yes. The Pizza Party Bundle is three 18-inch pies (cheese, pepperoni and Margherita), 24 slices, for $80. That's $11.97 less than buying the three pies separately.
How much are calzones?+
Calzones are $15 to $18. The Cheese and Create Your Own calzones are $15, the chicken, meatball, pepperoni and sausage calzones are $16.99, and the Cheesy Calzone is $18.
How much are drinks?+
A can of soda is $2.25 and a bottle of Poland Spring water is $1.99. Snapple is $3.25, Gatorade $3.55, Red Bull $3.65 and Boylan soda $3.75.
Hungry Now?
Slices from $4.99 at 145 1st Avenue. Open until 4am, and 5am Thursday–Saturday.
Order Online