What Is Double-Stacked Pizza?
Double-stacked pizza is two full New York-style pizzas baked together as a single pie, with an extra layer of mozzarella and toppings packed between the two crusts. The result is a taller, heartier slice with double the cheese pull and double the flavor in every bite. East Village Pizza created this style and it's become one of our most-ordered specialty items.
What Makes Our Double-Stacked Pizza Special
-
Two full pies, one pizza — not just a thicker crust, an entire second pizza baked inside
-
Extra mozzarella between layers — made fresh in-house every day
-
72-hour cold-fermented dough — for both layers, so it holds up without getting soggy
-
Any topping combination — Margherita, pepperoni, buffalo chicken, or build your own on either layer
-
An East Village exclusive — you won't find this at other Manhattan pizzerias
Fresh, Classic NYC Pizza — Made Daily
Every double-stacked pizza starts with the same hand-tossed, 72-hour cold-fermented dough we've used since 1997. We layer fresh-made mozzarella and your choice of toppings between two full pizzas, then bake until golden and bubbling. It's a bigger, more shareable take on the New York slice you already love.
Perfect For
-
Game day & group hangouts — more pizza per box, less waiting for seconds
-
Late-night cravings — available until 3AM (5AM weekends)
-
First-timers — if you've never had double-stacked pizza, this is the place it started
-
Anyone who thinks one layer of cheese isn't enough
How to Order Double-Stacked Pizza in NYC
-
Choose your toppings — pick the same or different toppings for each layer
-
​Order online for delivery or pickup, or call (212) 529-4545
-
​Ready in about 20-25 minutes — delivery to the East Village, Union Square, NYU, and Lower East Side
Double Stacked Pizza — Frequently Asked Questions
What is double-stacked pizza?
Double-stacked pizza is two full pizzas baked together as one pie, with extra mozzarella and toppings between the layers — an East Village Pizza original, served since 1997.
​
How much does double-stacked pizza cost?
Double-stacked pizza is priced as a specialty whole pie on our menu — see current pricing on our Menu page. Toppings can be customized on either layer.
​
Where can I get double-stacked pizza near me?
East Village Pizza, at 145 1st Ave in the East Village, is the original source for double-stacked pizza in NYC. We deliver to the East Village, Union Square, NYU, Lower East Side, and Alphabet City.
​
Can I customize the toppings on a double-stacked pizza?
Yes — you can choose any topping combination for each layer, from classic Margherita and pepperoni to buffalo chicken or a build-your-own pie.
​
Is double-stacked pizza available for delivery?
Yes, double-stacked pizza is available for both delivery and pickup, daily until 3AM (5AM Fridays and Saturdays).
​
Did East Village Pizza invent double-stacked pizza?
Double-stacked pizza has been a signature item at East Village Pizza since 1997, making us one of the originators of this style in NYC.
Made in the East Village Since 1997
East Village Pizza has been a Manhattan neighborhood institution for over 25 years. We're not a chain, not a franchise — just a family-run pizzeria that's been slinging some of NYC's best pizza at 145 1st Ave since before Yelp existed.
​
When you order a heart shaped pizza from us, it's made fresh by hand the same way every other pizza we make is. No shortcuts. Just real New York pizza, shaped with a little more intention.
Order the Double Stacked NYC Pizza
Stop by our East Village location or order online for fast pickup and delivery. Whether you’re a local or visiting NYC, East Village Pizza is your destination for authentic Manhattan pizza.