NYC's Original Heart-Shaped Pizza
Hand-shaped fresh daily at our East Village location — 145 1st Ave, NY 10003. Available for pickup or delivery across the East Village, Union Square, and Lower East Side. Choose any topping combination — Margherita, pepperoni, or build your own. Ready in about 20-25 minutes.
Perfect For
Valentine's Day
Order ahead — our most popular day of the year.
Anniversaries
A fun, memorable twist on date night.
Birthdays & Galentine's Parties
A shareable centerpiece.
"Just Because"
Available year-round, not just February.
Made by Hand, the Way Pizza Was Always Meant to Be
Some things are better when they're made from scratch, by hand, the way pizza was always meant to be made. Every heart-shaped pizza starts with the same 72-hour cold-fermented dough as the rest of our menu, hand-shaped to order — not cut from a round pie.
How to Order a Heart-Shaped Pizza
Call (212) 529-4545 or order online; specify heart-shaped pizza and your toppings.
Pick your toppings — Cheese, White, Pepperoni, or Margherita, or build your own.
Pickup at 145 1st Ave, or delivery across the East Village, Union Square, and Lower East Side.
Heart-Shaped Pizza — Frequently Asked Questions
How long has East Village Pizza made heart-shaped pizza?+
We've been hand-shaping heart-shaped pizzas since 1999 — NYC's original heart-shaped pizza.
What toppings can I get on a heart-shaped pizza?+
Choose any topping combination — Margherita, pepperoni, or build your own. Available in Cheese ($27.99), White ($29.99), Pepperoni ($29.99), and Margherita ($31.99).
Do I need to order a heart-shaped pizza ahead of time?+
Order ahead is recommended, especially around Valentine's Day — our most popular day for heart-shaped pizza. Ready in about 20-25 minutes any other time.
Is heart-shaped pizza only available on Valentine's Day?+
No — it's available year-round, not just February. Popular for anniversaries, birthdays, Galentine's parties, or just because.
A Manhattan Institution Since 1997
East Village Pizza has been a Manhattan neighborhood institution for over 25 years — a family-run pizzeria, not a chain, serving the East Village since 1997.