East Village Pizza Menu — NYC Slices, Whole Pies & More
Looking for the best pizza menu in Manhattan? East Village Pizza offers classic New York slices, whole pies, and specialty pizzas made fresh daily. From quick slices to full 18" pies, our menu is built for every craving.
All items available for pickup or delivery. Order through Grubhub or call us at (212) 529-4545. Walk-ins always welcome — slices ready to go all day.
Fan Favorites
Margherita
Pepperoni
Double Stacked — $46
Heart ShapedPizza by the Slice
Cheese Slice
$4.99
VegetarianPepperoni Slice
$6.25
Buffalo Chicken Slice
$6.89
SpicyWhite Slice
$6.5
VegetarianSicilian Pepperoni Slice
$6.89
Baked Ziti Slice
$6.89
Ziti pasta, ricotta, and tomato sauce on a pizza crust slice.
VegetarianExtra Cheese Slice
$6.5
VegetarianMargherita Slice
$6.89
VegetarianBBQ Chicken Slice
$6.89
Sicilian Slice
$5.5
VegetarianMushroom Slice
$5.89
VegetarianVegetable Slice
$6.89
Spinach, broccoli, mushroom, tomatoes, peppers, and olives.
Vegetarian
Whole 18" Pizzas
Cheese Pizza 18"
$25
VegetarianCreate Your Own Pizza 18"
$25.92
Buffalo Chicken Pizza 18"
$31.99
Sicilian Pie 16"
$26.99
VegetarianPepperoni Jalapeno Pizza 18"
$30.99
SpicyCombo - Everything Pizza 18"
$35.35
Vegetable Pizza 18"
$31.99
VegetarianMushroom Pizza 18"
$27.99
VegetarianBaked Ziti 18"
$30.99
VegetarianExtra Cheese Pizza 18"
$27.99
VegetarianMargherita Pizza 18"
$31.99
VegetarianPepperoni (Beef) Pizza 18"
$27.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza 18"
$32.99
Sicilian Pepperoni Pie 16"
$29
White Pizza 18"
$27.99
VegetarianMeat Lover Pizza 18"
$33.11
Pepperoni Sausage Pizza 18"
$30.99
Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza 18"
$30.99
Double-Stacked Pizza
Double Stacked Pizza 18"
$46
Two full 18-inch pies baked together as one, with extra mozzarella and your choice of toppings sandwiched between the layers — an East Village Pizza original, served since 1997.
Heart-Shaped Pizza
Heart-Shaped Cheese Pizza
$27.99
VegetarianHeart-Shaped White Pizza
$29.99
VegetarianHeart-Shaped Pepperoni Pizza
$29.99
Heart-Shaped Margherita Pizza
$31.99
Vegetarian
Sicilian Square Pizza
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
$26.99
VegetarianSicilian Margherita Pizza
$31.99
VegetarianSicilian Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$31.99
Sicilian White Pizza
$29
VegetarianSicilian Pepperoni Pizza
$29.99
Sicilian Meat Lovers Pizza
$31.99
Create Your Own Sicilian Pizza
$26.99
Gluten-Free Pizza (12")
Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza 12"
$15.99
VegetarianCreate Your Own Gluten-Free Pizza 12"
$15.99
Gluten-Free Olives Pizza 12"
$19.99
VegetarianGluten-Free White Pizza 12"
$20
VegetarianGluten-Free Vegetable Pizza 12"
$24.99
VegetarianGluten-Free Margherita Pizza 12"
$24.99
VegetarianGluten-Free Mushroom Pizza 12"
$20
Vegetarian
Calzones
Create Your Own Calzone
$15
BBQ Chicken Calzone
$16.99
Chicken Calzone
$15
Cheese Calzone
$15
VegetarianPepperoni Calzone
$16.99
Buffalo Chicken Calzone
$16.99
Meatball Calzone
$16.99
Mozzarella Rolls
Create Your Own Mozzarella Roll
$15
Pepperoni Mozzarella Roll
$16.99
BBQ Chicken & Mozzarella Roll
$17.99
Broccoli & Mozzarella Roll
$15.99
VegetarianChicken & Mozzarella Roll
$16.99
Buffalo Chicken & Mozzarella Roll
$17.99
Sausage & Mozzarella Roll
$16.99
Spinach & Mozzarella Roll
$15.99
Vegetarian
Garlic Knots & Cheesy Extras
Cheesy Garlic Knots
$13
VegetarianCheesy Calzone
$18
VegetarianCheesy Meatball Parm
$17
Cheesy Garlic Knots Parm
$16
VegetarianCheesy Garlic Knots Parm with Pepperoni
$18
Side Orders
Garlic Knots (6 Pieces)
$4.5
VegetarianMeatballs (6 Pieces)
$8.99
Desserts
Tiramisu
$8
VegetarianCheesecake
$6
Vegetarian
Sauces & Dressings
Blue Cheese (2 oz.)
$1.75
VegetarianRanch (2 oz.)
$1.75
VegetarianMarinara (2 oz.)
$1.75
Vegetarian
Beverages
Bottled Water (Poland Spring)
$1.98
VegetarianGatorade
$3.35
Orange, Riptide Rush, Cool Blue, or Lemon Lime.
VegetarianCanned Soda
$2.25
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Fanta, Seltzer Water, Ginger Ale, or Root Beer.
VegetarianSnapple
$3.25
Lemon Iced Tea, Diet Lemon Iced Tea, Peach Tea, or Diet Peach Tea.
Vegetarian
NYC Pizza Made Fresh Daily — Slices from $4.99
East Village Pizza has been making classic New York-style pizza at 145 1st Avenue since 1997. Every slice starts with 72-hour cold-fermented dough, simple tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella — made in-house every day, no exceptions.
Order by the slice for $4.99, build your own 18" whole pie, or try something from the menu that you won't find anywhere else: the double-stacked pizza, heart-shaped pies, and a full gluten-free menu.
Order online via Grubhub or call (212) 529-4545. Pickup and delivery available. Open until 4am Sun–Wed, 5am Thu–Sat.
Pizza Menu FAQ
How much is a pizza in NYC?+
At East Village Pizza, slices start at $4.99 and whole 18" pies start at $25. Specialty pies like our double-stacked or heart-shaped pizza range from $30-$46.
Do you have gluten-free pizza?+
Yes, a full 12" gluten-free menu is available: Cheese, White, Margherita, Vegetable, Mushroom, Olives, or build your own.
Can I customize my pizza?+
Yes — the Create Your Own 18" pizza starts at $25.92 with toppings added from $3.50. A gluten-free create-your-own is also available for $15.99.
What time does the kitchen close?+
We serve food until close — 4am Sunday through Wednesday and 5am Thursday through Saturday. Same menu all day and night.
What is double-stacked pizza?+
Double-stacked pizza is two full New York-style pizzas baked together as one pie, with extra mozzarella and your choice of toppings packed between the two crusts — an East Village Pizza original, served since 1997.